Fast Speeds and Low Latency-But has Reliability Slipped in Telecom Networks?

Rohit Narayan, Global Director, Telecom, nVent

Rohit Narayan, Global Director, Telecom, nVent

As we moved to voice in cellular networks, we have been taught to have lower expectations, and even today some 30 years later, as a consumer, we acceptthat some phone calls will not be completed, and we just try again if a call drops off.  Having a mobile voice service was so liberating, but we saw that reliability was somewhat compromised. We also started to see cellular sites having smaller battery back up times of 1-4 hours as a contrast to the early days.

Move then to fixed and mobile data communications and packet switching.  Well, what the heck, these arejust packets of data that need to be reassembled on the other side. If we don’t transmit it all, we can just re-transmit. Packet switching gave us a great ability to transmit all the data intact eventually, and, in some cases, we began to pay less attention to noise and bit error rates. If the bit error rate is high, it just results in re-transmission until all packet are received on the other side.  How many times have we done a speed test and it showed reasonable speeds,yet it felt real slow when you were trying to do some work? This did not affect data as much as voice over data where latency was more importantas it was important to transmit all or most of the packets of data across in reasonable time—to re-construct the voice at the other end so one could have a meaningful conversation. How irritating is it when you see news channel reporters on live news waiting for a second or two before replying? We have experienced all this and hey it is a nuisance, but we can live with it.

But what is about to happen with the advent of 5G into our lives in terms of compromising reliability with more data speeds and latency is going to be an era of some hard lessons. Although with a bit of foresight, we can avoid this. Let us look at what we use mobile data for today.  A lot of browsing, news consumption, online shopping, socializing, messaging, audio and video calls using apps like WhatsApp, Messenger, Skype, and Viber, some work-related activities, and perhaps very occasional emergency services messaging and voice calls. Of course, when we lose our connectivity, we get extremely agitated but it is not mission critical nor life threatening in most cases.

With the availability of 5G, the industry is getting really excited about fast speeds and low latency and what this would enable. It will enable applications like smart parking, security and surveillance, car-to-car communication, management on power grids, edge computing, car and home automation, water and gas leak detection and communication, maybe remote surgery and robotics, and a whole lot of IoT device communication. Now losing some of these applications will not be about losing social connectivity, but some of these could be critical and, in some cases, life threatening. So, will the 5G network using a combination of macro cell sites and small cell sites be robust enough in its reliability to step up to this task? I expect that the answer is no. This is the first time I am seeing parts of telecommunications network, in particular the 5G small cells, operating with no backup battery time at all. So if there is mains power lost, then a whole area may lose coverage. What may be inevitable with time is that some significant catastrophes in dense cities would occur due to this high dependability before we realize this compromised reliability in our 5G network. And it will almost certainly be too late to go back and fix this by then.

It is not as simple as adding batteries to small cell sites to get the reliability up. The management and maintenance of batteries over a long period of time in an outdoor environment with large temperature variations is a technical nightmare for telecom operators. It is certainly not possible to get 4-10 hour battery back-up as that would make the cost of these sites uneconomical.

Another area of reliability in 5G small cells that may be compromised is a potentially higher susceptibility to noise and transients. Given the tight locations that these small cells will be installed in, the operator will not have the luxury of space and cost to install grounding and protection systems with the same performance as they would in the vast network today. Grounding and protection system reduce noise and increase resilience against transients.  Furthermore, as quadrature amplitude modulation techniques are inevitable in 5G equipment to get the latency and speeds, theywouldbe more susceptible to noise than, say, frequency-based modulation methods. Carriers like AT&T in the U.S. have given this aspect of the small cell design considerable thought and are likely to have networks that would have higher reliability and resilience against noise and transients.

In summary, we have seen our reliance on telecommunications increase significantly in the last four decades, but hidden and unknown to most of us are some aspects of the infrastructure design where reliability is compromised. My advice to users of this modern telecommunications network is to be cautious about connecting mission-critical and potential life-saving applications to modern networks, without due considerations about reliability. In the meantime, go enjoy the higher speeds and low latency for everything else.

Read Also

Considering the Real Value of Artificial Intelligence In Higher Education

Considering the Real Value of Artificial Intelligence In Higher...

Elon Turner, Director of Infrastructure & Telecommunication Services, University of Arkansas
Telecom & Grid Modernization (Working Title)

Telecom & Grid Modernization (Working Title)

Kymberly Traylor, Director of Network & Telecommunications, JEA
The Ever-Evolving Telco Industry

The Ever-Evolving Telco Industry

Jeffrey Hedberg, Chief Executive Office, Wind Tre
Fast Speeds and Low Latency-But has Reliability Slipped in Telecom Networks?

Fast Speeds and Low Latency-But has Reliability Slipped in Telecom...

Rohit Narayan, Global Director, Telecom, nVent
Embracing Technology to Optimize Customer Experiences

Embracing Technology to Optimize Customer Experiences

Mujtanibul Ahmed Sakib, Head of Customer Experience, Banglalink Digital Communication